Retrofit or rebuild: a place-led approach at Better Queensway
When is it right to save a building? Gareth Atkinson shares the positive impact a retrofit-first approach to regeneration can deliver
At Better Queensway in Southend on Sea, four aging 1970s tower blocks stand in the middle of Southend’s regeneration site, with the council to decide whether to save them or rebuild.
Better Queensway is a masterplan transforming the central area of Southend, and is a fantastic example of the ways system thinking can help to shape how a project is delivered.
We’re civil, structural, transport and building services engineers working with dRMM and LDA on the project, which includes creating greener and safer streets by reducing the highway footprint, and reducing flood risk by repurposing abandoned underpasses as surface water storage, as part of a wider SuDS system. It shows how existing assets can be adapted to meet today's challenges.
So what does the future hold for the four tower blocks at the heart of the site, what could be achieved through retrofit?
Gareth Atkinson, senior director and head of our London studio, was recently interviewed by Toby Fox, behind the ‘1.5m New Homes: the local Government Challenge’ campaign, to discuss.
In the episode, Gareth is joined by Glyn Halksworth, director of regeneration, housing and regulatory services at Southend-on-Sea Council, to make the case for the positive impact retrofit. Watch the full episode here:
Glyn begins by setting out the context behind the decisions surrounding the tower blocks: “There was hunch amongst the team, that we should understand the embodied carbon of the decision, and the potential for what we believe to be structurally sound buildings to be re-provided as something more suitable for the modern market.
“Retrofitting doesn’t just come down to cost. As a local authority we also need to understand the numbers, the felt sense of a place and how the embodied carbon stacks up. It’s about gathering robust detail, data and resident sentiment, and knowing it is the right way forward. That’s what regeneration is about.”
Gareth adds: “Across the industry, the status quo has been to knock down and start again, but the case for retrofit is becoming more prevalent. The reality is we can rework or reuse these buildings to create fantastic places for the future, while using less carbon.
“We have got to look at building itself to look at its design life, but it’s also about retrofit of the place. It’s important we work with design teams to look at the public realm and spaces in between, to see how retrofit can work as part of a cohesive new, more sustainable masterplan.”
In the interview, Gareth goes on to share:
- The importance of reusing for sustainability, and the impact on saving carbon and climate resilience
- How retrofit can help deliver more homes and help create places and spaces that thrive
- The types of information and detailed analysis which can be gathered to determine whether to retrofit, including historic data, structural drawings and visual assessments
Material reuse and retrofit is central to our approach at Civic, and is central to many of our projects.
Gareth chairs NLA's Net Zero Panel, and we were also one of the founding members of The Engineers Reuse Collective, a not-for-profit group committed to accelerating reuse in the built environment to support the transition of the UK’s construction industry to Net Zero Carbon, and we are members of Accelerate Concrete Decarbonisation Group (ACDG).
Read Gareth's piece on 'Retrofit reimagined: building less and sharing more' here.